You are here: Home / Agencies and Offices / Perry County OSU Extension / DICAMBA BATTLES CONTINUE: COURT ALLOWS DICAMBA USE

DICAMBA BATTLES CONTINUE: COURT ALLOWS DICAMBA USE

There was a great deal of action last Friday in the case that vacated the registrations of XtendiMax, Engenia and FeXapan dicamba-based products. Despite a barrage of court filings on Friday, however, nothing has changed the current legal status of the dicamba products in Ohio, and Ohio growers may use existing stocks of the products now but must end use by June 30, 2020.

 

DICAMBA BATTLES CONTINUE: COURT ALLOWS DICAMBA USE

 

Farm Office Blog

Dicamba battles continue: court allows dicamba use

Monday, June 22nd, 2020

Written by Peggy Kirk Hall, Associate Professor, Agricultural & Resource Law

 

There was a great deal of action last Friday in the case that vacated the registrations of XtendiMax, Engenia and FeXapan dicamba-based products.  Despite a barrage of court filings on Friday, however, nothing has changed the current legal status of the dicamba products in Ohio, and Ohio growers may use existing stocks of the products now but must end use by June 30, 2020.

 

Here’s a rundown of the orders that the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued in the case last Friday:

  • The court denied the emergency motion that the petitioners (National Family Farm Coalition, Center for Food Safety, Center for Biological Diversity, and Pesticide Action Network North America) filed on June 13.  That motion asked the court to enforce its previous mandate to vacate the registrations, to prevent any further use of the products, and to hold the EPA in contempt for issuing the Cancellation Order the agency had made that allowed continued use of existing stocks of the products.  The court did not provide its reasoning for denying the motion.
  • The court granted amicus curiae (friend of the court) status to CropLife America and American Farm Bureau (representing  itself as well as national soybean, cotton, wheat, corn and sorghum association interest.)  Those parties filed their amicus curiae briefs in support of the EPA’s Cancellation Order and in opposition to the petitioners' emergency motion.
  • The court granted also emergency motions to intervene in the case filed by BASF Corporation, maker of Engenia, and DuPont (Corteva) , maker of FeXapan.   The companies argued that they did not know that the  scope of the court’s order on Bayer's XtendiMax product registration would also affect their dicamba product registrations and they should now be permitted an opportunity to defend their products.
  • BASF filed a motion asking the court to recall the court's mandate that had cancelled the registrations of the products, claiming that the court had not followed appropriate procedural rules.  In its brief, BASF also suggested that te company would be filing petitions for rehearing since BASF had not had an opportunity to be heard when the court vacated the registration of its Engenia product.
  • The court ordered the original petitioners to file a brief in response to BASF’s motion to recall the mandate by June 23, and for BASF to reply to that brief by June 24.

 

The companies that make the dicamba products clearly intend to challenge the vacatur of their product registrations, even though the EPA's Cancellation Order allows continued use of existing stocks of the products until July 30, 2020.   This dicamba battle is not yet over, and we'll keep you posted on new developments.

 

Read our previous posts on the court's vacatur in National Family Farm Coalition here, on the EPA's Cancellation Order here, and on the Ohio Department of Agriculture's ruling on use of the products in Ohio here.

Upcoming Events
Shawnee First Friday Farmers Market July 3, 2020 Jul 03, 2020 05:00 PM - 07:00 PM — Intersection of St Rts 93 and 155 - Shawnee, OH 43782
Free Legal Clinic July 7, 2020 Jul 07, 2020 03:30 PM - 05:00 PM — Perry County Courthouse - 105 N Main St, New Lexington, OH 43764
Blood Drive Thornville Masonic Lodge Saturday, July 11, 2020 Jul 11, 2020 08:00 AM - 01:00 PM — Thornville Masonic Lodge #521 - 44 E Columbus St, Thornville, OH 43076
Rally 4 Recovery "Virtual" Recovery Jam 2020 Jul 11, 2020 06:00 PM - 10:00 PM — Facbook and First United Methodist Church - 126 S High St, New Lexington, OH 43764
July 2020 Shawnee Second Saturday Jul 11, 2020 07:00 PM - 09:00 PM — Historic Main Street - Shawnee, OH 43782
Upcoming events…